I’ve been doing a lot of thinking. Just ask my wife. She hates it when I do a lot of thinking, as it tends to end up with me dressed up in her clothes and parading around the house as “Dorothy”. Some people, of a cynical disposition, might argue that I am a closet transvestite and that when caught by Mrs A, I construct an elaborate explanation that not only explans away my fetish, but also promotes an aspirational intellectual nature. This is, however, pure bunkum. If I was a transvestite, I would call myself Celeste or Chanel; not Dorothy. It would be a curious thing to label myself as a frump even before I had started. I mean – who is called Dorothy?! Except for Dot Cotton, of course, who is called Dorothy. I never figured out Dr Leg’s first name though. He looks like a David.
But turn boldly away from my digression.
I have been grappling with the single common issue inherent in some of my favourite childhood tales. In short, I have been trying to come to terms with the impossibility of certain major events that happened in such stories.
My favourite story by far was The Magic Porridge Pot. For a man of my ever-expanding girth and density, being exposed in my formative years to the idea of an endless source of food explains a great deal. It has shaped me. The sphere in to which I am evolving can be directly attributed, I think, to the central precept of The Magic Porridge Pot. In the words of Johnny Morris, anthropomorphist and High Priestess in the masons, “Thanks to The Magic Porridge Pot, I am becoming a fat bastard.”
Let us remind ourselves of what happened in The Magic Porridge Pot. Essentially, you had a family in poverty, close to starvation. They came in to possession of a large cooking pot, which had the uncanny ability to spontaneously produce delicious piping hot porridge at the mention of a magic word. A second magic word was used to cease the flow of porridge from some never-ending metaphysical source. The sting in the tail with this story, was that they forgot the magic word used to turn off the porridge flow and it got completely out of hand. The porridge kept coming; it spilled out of the pot, filled the kitchen, burst out of the little cottage in a deluge and flowed down the street in a raging torrent. In proportion, at least, it was a bit like when you spill some tea on the sofa at your mum’s house.
I will say at this point that while the story had an obvious moral to it – don’t order too much porridge – as a child this never worried me. Ever a fat man trapped inside a medium-sized man’s body, the idea of swimming in delicious, piping-hot porridge always presented itself to me as an enviable scenario.
But these days, I can’t help but wonder how the hell they did it. How does a seemingly normal cooking pot manage to produce – quite spontaneously – an infinite supply of ready-cooked porridge? How was it done?
I think to answer this question, we need to look at the entire episode with more of a critical eye than we might be accustomed to. Firstly, it is important to challenge the notion that the supply of porridge was infinite. This would mean an infinite supply of oats and and infinite supply of milk, to make the porridge; and that would mean an infinite amount of space for the porridge source to be contained within. Infinity, while a fascinating area of physics and metaphysics, can surely only exist once, by its very nature. The premise of The Magic Porridge Pot would suggest that infinity is given over fully to some vast porridge reservoir. It seems ridiculous. Where would everything else go? I don’t see stored porridge everywhere I look. Do you?
The second precept that we need to tackle, is the notion of The Magic Porridge Pot being a “normal” pot. Actually, there is no real evidence that this was the case. It may have looked normal – in the same way that a magician’s magic chest looks normal – but nobody in the poor cottage actually examined it in any detail, by my recollection. My guess is that the pot must have had a discretely positioned inlet, through which the “endless supply” of porridge poured. Positioned at the base of the pot, such an inlet would never have been discovered since it was always covered by porridge. As soon as the porridge was dished out, more porridge appeared – welling up, no doubt, from the base of the pot. From the hidden inlet.
Such a mechanical device would explain our seemingly supernatural phenomenon, quite easily. The hidden inlet would be connected to a pipe, which in turn, would be connected to a source of porridge, able to be pumped through to the pot on demand. To flood an entire cottage and to fill a street, the source of the porridge must admittedly have been ample; but this is not to say it was infinite. My guess is that there was probably some huge vat, within half a mile of the cottage, connected to the cottage by an underground conduit (being underground would have a dual purpose. It would remain hidden from sight, thus sustaining the illusion of a magic pot being filled spontaneously with porridge from a metaphysical source; and it would be well insulated from the cold, thus ensuring that the porridge remained piping hot as it travelled through half a mile of pipe).
Of course, this leaves one remaining mystery. The impact of the magic word. A magic word (or mantra) was used to bring forth the porridge; and a magic word (or mantra) was used to cease its flow. So our question is: If the supplier of the porridge is half a mile away, how do they control the flow of porridge in reponse to the magic invocation?
The answer is disappointing in its mundanity. In the modern age, simple radio technology would be able to transmit the invocation across half a mile. A well-hidden transmitting “listening” device, placed within the kitchen of the cottage, would allow the controller of the porridge flow to listen in to any conversations taking place within the vicinity of the pot. On hearing the magic word or mantra, the flow could be activated. Now, given that the story was created before the advent of radio technology, we must look for an alternative explanation. But it isn’t hard to find! We have already surmised that there is a pipe running from the source of the porridge to the kitchen – and that this pipe is then connected to the inlet on the porridge pot. It takes little imagination to conclude that a second pipe was run alongside the first. Once again hidden underground, this second pipe was empty, and was simply used as a very crude telephone line. Anything said in the kitchen of the cottage would echo down the pipe, to be heard by the controller of the porridge flow. On being uttered, the invocation for porridge could be immediately acted upon. It would seem, to a supersitious person living in the cottage, that they truly did have a Magic Porridge Pot, connected to an infinite supply of delicious piping hot porridge, that could be activated on the utterance of a simple invocation.
And why would we want to dispel the myth for them? In a way, we wouldn’t. Being supplied with porridge in this way meant that an impoverished family was well-fed, while at the same time was given every reason to believe in a metaphysical force much greater than itself. This must have been a comfort not only to the belly, but to the spirit as well. In this, we can applaud the motives of the person or persons who supplied the porridge. It is also laudable that the porridge was supplied in such a way that the family did not feel obligated for the charity. Since it was coming from a metaphysical source (so they believed) it was seen as a gift; and they needed to offer nothing in return but their gratitude.
The problem comes, of course, in the fact the suppliers of the porridge did not turn the flow off when the second invocation was not made. A great deal of damage was caused because the suppliers of the porridge were trying to make some kind of moral point. Don’t order too much porridge. The damage sustained by the cottage – and the environment outside – does seem an excessive and disproportionate way for such a moral point to be made. It is possible, of course, that when the porridge filled up the kitchen, the telephonic pipe was blocked and so the suppliers of the porridge, being half a mile away, were unaware of the drama that was unfolding. It is possible…but the jury is out. You would have though they would have planned for such a scenario, and would have some contingency at hand.
Who am I to judge, though?
The point is, I have worked out the mystery of The Magic Porridge Pot. I have seen through the tricks and devices used. They were clever and have sustained a wonderful story for many, many years. But at its source, the trickery was simple. Now that I have exploded the myth, I strongly believe that the story should be retitled: The Cunningly Manufactured Illusion, In Which A Pot With A Hidden Inlet Was Connected To A Large Vat Some Half A Mile Away, A Vat Filled With Delicious Porridge And Kept Piping Hot By An Internal Heating Mechanism, And Whereby (Thanks to a Second Pipe Used For Telephonic Voice Transmission) The Illusion Was Created That A Magic Word (or Mantra) Could Be Employed To Access An Infinite Supply Of Delicious Piping Hot Porridge.
A much more accurate title, I think.











